Gatsby was created to satisfy the needs and comforts of travellers and local Torontonians alike. Windsor Arms’ newest restaurant is opened on a temporarily modified schedule for patio service from noon until 9PM every day. We feature over 60 local craft drafts and beers including a new menu full of delectable comfort foods. Gatsby also has a premium international wine selection, which is the proud recipient of the Award of Excellence by Wine Spectator for five consecutive years.
Interior designer Jacques Dinel of Dinel Designs brought British influence to the restaurant, setting the atmosphere of luxurious comfort. The Living Room is decorated with original print art from the UK and a formal dining area with original Charles Pachter paintings. Furnished with oversized Chesterfields and comfortable leather seating, The Living Room is perfect for conducting your meetings, get-togethers or hosting formal dining events.
Don’t mind my ratings , you go and have good time. Anyway, main course is tasty and as far as appetizers go, don’t be a fusion restaurant while you are not. Stay classic And gain respect.
Great welcome by the friendly doorman. Lot of ambiance in this old hotel with great charm n character. We were celebrating grand parents anniversary. So it was the right fit. Food was delicious. Highly recommend the grilled salmon cooked just right. Those of us who tried steak thought it was superb. Their Okra appetizer was superb. Good wine at a very reasonable price. The very knowledgeable waiter topped it all with excellent service. Will definitely dine there again for most of our special occasions. Highly recommend it to those who want high quality.
Thoroughly enjoyed my visit. Shall return to have afternoon tea sometime.
We had a reservation at The Gatsby but were seated in a different restaurant in the hotel without any explanation. When another diner questioned the server, she was told they rented out The Gatsby for a private function, but still took reservations. The Winterlicious menu was disappointing.
Overall it was priced more for the name then the food
Great service and fun ambiance. The food was good but the mains were a bit simple. Portion size was good
No I would not recommend this restaurant. It is old, tired and lost it’s charm. Food was not worth the value. It was in the highest price range of Winterlicous lunch menu so I expected it to be close to the other restaurants in that range. At least they could have cleaned the windows. Paint was chipped. Washroom was clean by lacked amenities from what I thought should be in a well respected hotel.
Loved this place! Great ambiance, live music, service, and food. It’s not crowded at all, so that makes it easy to talk to the person you’re with since it’s quiet, and the live music gives a nice elegant feel to the restaurant. The drinks were also spectacular, as was the food. Waiter was also very kind. Will definitely be coming back here.
A friend recommended Gatsby and I booked a table for my wife and I on a Saturday evening. We had a very nice evening in this restaurant, very quiet and nice atmosphere, the waiter was very efficient and nice, very good food. We will go back.
We order the salmon with beef sauce and quinoa, it was amazing! we paired it with a Rose wine to die for! The portion was not big, but after the appetizer and the main dish we where so satisfied we didn’t even need dessert. It’s a really beautiful place and we really enjoy the service.
Ugly design, even for an imaginary speakeasy. Chairs especially poor–my nose was about plate level when food arrived and I am not short. Overrated and overpriced.